Frugal Living on the Homestead: Make Homemade Yogurt

Homemade Yogurt

When we started planning our transition to a homesteading lifestyle, one of the things I tackled first was trying to find ways to make some of the things we eat the most. For me, yogurt is on the top of the list!

I eat yogurt every…single…day. I have always struggled a little from digestive issues, and yogurt seemed to help regulate the problem. I figured I was spending about $10-$15 per week on yogurt. Once I realized that I could make a gallon of yogurt for little more than the price of a gallon of milk, I knew it was worth my time and effort. Luckily, it doesn’t take a whole lot of effort…just a little wait time.

Since learning how to make my own yogurt, I have now transitioned to making organic yogurt. Even considering the purchase of organic milk, I am still at a considerable savings from what I was previously spending. The yogurt lasts over a month in the refrigerator (although I run out long before the yogurt has gone bad).

One thing that has helped stay prepared for my yogurt-making excursions is keeping a steady supply of organic milk in the freezer. It still blows my mind that you can freeze milk! We just pour a little off the top (to allow room for expanding when frozen) and plop it down in our freezer.

When we’re ready for a new gallon, we just set it in the kitchen sink the night before. It is not totally thawed in the morning, but it has a big milk ice cube floating in the middle. There usually is enough to pour out for our daily need. We just pop it in the refrigerator in the morning and off we go.

How to Make Homemade Yogurt

  1. Heat one gallon of milk in a crockpot on high for 2.5 hours. When it is done, the outside will look bubbly and there may be a layer of dried milk across the top.

2. Cool the milk to 110 degrees. You can do this by waiting a long time, or pouring it into a different pan and put in a water bath for around 5 minutes. I use a candy thermometer to read an exact temperature. I have also heard that it if you can dip your pinky in for three seconds without getting burned that it is the correct temperature. Whatever suits your fancy!

3. Pour the milk back into the warm crock. Add your yogurt starter. I buy organic yogurt and freeze it in ice cube trays. Two cubes is enough to turn the whole gallon of milk into yogurt. Just set them out to thaw while you are heating your milk. Make sure you choose a yogurt that only has two ingredients: milk and several yogurt cultures.

4. Stir the mixture well. Put the lid back on the crock and wrap it in a thick towel. I use a beach towel.

5. Do not touch it for 8 hours. Yogurt bacteria do not like to be moved when they are working their magic. After the 8 hours, unwrap the yogurt and put it in the refrigerator to cool.

6. After cooling, the yogurt is ready to eat. It will be runnier than yogurt you purchase at the store. It works good for smoothies when it is thicker. I prefer a thicker yogurt to eat so I strain the whey out of my yogurt before I eat it. I line a colander with coffee filters, and fill it up with the yogurt. Put the colander into a larger dish so the whey strains in. Then I cover the yogurt with a coffee filter and sometimes put a ziplock bag full of water on top of it to apply a little pressure. I put that back in the refrigerator while it strains. The longer you let it strain, the thicker it gets.  


Add a little raw honey, fresh berries, and granola, and you have yourself quite a treat!

What have you tried to make from scratch to save some money? Share your comments below.


One thought on “Frugal Living on the Homestead: Make Homemade Yogurt

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s